The Hefty Bag Approach to Dating

Has anyone yet compared the success rate of dating the old fashioned way, ten years ago, back before Internet personals were invented -- and the new, improved Internet way?
Are there any statistics that show a greater satisfaction with relationships, more stable and lasting marriages?
Or has Internet dating actually eroded our ability to meet and relate?
Here are some themes I hope to explore in Brain Dancing:
1. An endless stream of new prospects has made dates less precious, more expendable. It's created what I call the "Hefty Bag" approach to dating. Dates are rapidly trashed (or recycled.) As if Internet dates somehow aren't "real" people -- so real feelings don't matter.
2. The anonymity of personal ads has created an explosion in "casual encounters," "hookups" just for sex, "booty calls", swinger ads and "NSA" affairs. Were people really into so much no strings attached sex ten years ago -- before the Internet made it so anonymous and easy?
3. Online dating has made infidelity a profitable business -- 28% of the 40 million American adults who use Internet personals are actually married.
4. Despite the proliferation in Internet dating services -- few people seem to create sustainable relationships this way. Out of my wide circle of personal friends, I know only 4 couples who have met and married through personal ads. (And of those, one resulted in a divorce one year later.). Virtually all of my single friends use Internet personals -- but very few of these people seem to make it past the first date with anyone.
5. Internet personal ads are often blatantly dishonest. Every man I know who has tried Internet dating services complains that the majority of the photographs that women place are at least ten years old and that women about their age. (One guy I spoke with on the phone when I was screening prospective dates said, sarcastically, "Photoshop is a girl's best friend." Women complain that the men they meet are often married and looking for some side play--or recently separated, on the rebound and just looking for quick, casual sex -- even though their ad states they're single and "looking for a serious relationship".
6. The upside? Internet ads bring wonderful new friends into our lives who we might have never met otherwise -- or put us in touch with people we already met before ("in the real world") but somehow didn't connect with. Internet ads also help people find "that needle in a haystack" -- the one person in the world who can share a very narrow, political interest, religion, dietary preference, race, geographic region, kink or hobby.
Ayurvedic personal ads that match you by dosha? Hey, why not.

3 comments:
Okay, here are MY online dating stats:
Met my partner through online dating. Been together for more than a couple of years...doin' fine.
Work friend: met her hubby through salon.com--spring street (a little better than Match.com if you've got a brain, by the way.
My fiddle teacher met her hubby through a Christian online dating service.
Friend at work met her fiance (they've lived together for several years and are now marrying)...
I have more to add (I'll do that later)...Do those four trump your four, gigi?
Here's a better statistic: pre-online dating, what was the likelihood that people would pick ill-chosen dates and/or partners?
Now, since the advent of online dating: what is the statistical number of people who tend to pick ill-chosen dates and or partners? I think that the number of naive dumbasses probably remains a statistical constant.
When you date online you have to keep your cool--don't get overly enthusiastic until you really know the person, etc. Same kind of advice that would have been given in the past. Duh.
Anon, I am glad to hear it worked for you, but I think Gigi has it right, it is mostly an absurd experience in cataloge shopping, only this time with people. I think that if you are young, and if you fit a particular "type" then it can work, but that same type seems also to be in the highest demand anyway. Basically, if you are very successfull and very attractive and very photogenic it is easy to date.
I tried it, I also tried all the regular avenues. In the end my experiences with traditional dating approachs worked much better than on line, but that makes sense for me, what ever it is that women find attractive in me has always been much more about "presence" and less about raw looks.
Oh well, when I met my wife at a party I hit her with two ex wives, three kids and a mini van in the first thirty minutes. Figured she would run. Nope, and today I can say I have never been happier.
Online dating allows people to focus in on a particular type, which can be very constrictive for most people. People focus in on physical traits like age, height, hair, income, etc. yet they don't focus on whether they're a nice person or not.
In real life you can say "I only like blondes" but then a brunette will come along and blow your whole theory. Honestly, people just don't know what they're really interested in when they look online.
Post a Comment
Let us know what you think!