Single (again) during the holidays.



Sunday, my girlfriend broke down in tears in the middle of a dance. It's been a rough time for her -- her grandparents just passed away, she has the same economic struggles we're all facing, and her boyfriend seems kind of indifferent to her emotional turmoil. She wanted to be held, supported, you know -- cuddled. So she dragged me to a brunch party hosted by Reid, the suddenly famous host of the Cuddle Party.

Even though a cuddle brunch seems innocuous enough, I had a bad feeling in my gut about it, but I wanted her to feel better, so we picked up some eggs and went there.

We left our shoes in the hall of a small but beautifully decorated classic San Francisco flat, and Reid, who has shaggy blonde hair, was much cuter and, well -- huggable -- that I possibly expected, welcomed us with, of course, a fabulous warm hug and a big beaming smile. He was wearing printed flannel pajamas, though it was at least 3 in the afternoon. (Reid always wears PJs -- that's the de rigeur attire for the Cuddle Party.) I was starting to cheer up. But still, that vague "this is not right feeling" was stalking me.

When we walked into the kitchen I knew why: there was my ex -- and the (boo, hiss!) woman who snagged him away. I'll call her Bozo Hair, to protect her identity. She's a frumpy middle aged woman with this enormous pouf of frizzy hair dyed Ronald Mc Donald Red. Ok, Bozo the Clown Red. It is not a color of hair that exists in nature, even if you're Celtic. Contrasting the frizz of hair (in which, as usual, there were about an inch of gray roots showing), she was wearing one of her typically unflattering, loud, garish neo Goddess outfits -- a pair of widelegged printed purple hipster yoga pants that shouldn't even be manufactured in her size. (Some people do not have a licence to wear stretch pants.) It looked like they had both been out partying all night and rolled in still awake and wearing whatever they had on the night before. He had deep dark circles under his eyes, and they both looked kind of gray. Ex put on a show keeping himself busy fetching heaping plates of food to feed Bozo, which she scarfed up nervously. It was like watching someone fatten up a calf for slaughter.

Bitter? Moi? Nine months have passed. I recovered, therapized, workshopped and soothed myself into a wiser woman with higher self esteem. I tossed out every card and gift he ever gave me. (Except the vibrating razor. It's a wierd narcissic gift, but my legs have never been smoother.) I abandoned my communities and avoided every possible party where I might run into him. But once in a while, I run into THEM -- and in Eckart Tolle's words, it retriggers the "pain body" of grief.

So here's my worst nightmare, right? Him with HER (boo, hiss!) in a VERY small cuddle party! Yikes.

I looked around. The flat was cramped. There was no possible place for cuddling to happen except the bedroom. This was not looking promising.

I pulled my girlfriend aside and whispered, urgently:

"Get me out of here!"

"Let's eat first, I'm starved," she said.

There was one seat available -- of course, the one directly across from "them." Bozo made an awkward attempt to be polite (she always has this nonchalant touchy feely attitude of: "Why won't you be friends with me? We're all just one big polyamorous happy family, why can't we love one another, blah blah blah, San Francisco New Age Double Speak.)

The fact is, she "got" him for only one reason: She was willing to stalk a partnered man, she knew he was a cheater, and she was willing to tolerate it. I asked for respect, honesty, transparency and commitment. He didn't give it to me either, so I left, with my self respect intact.

She continues to look the other way. He continues to "pretend" to be her boyfriend while he continued to chase me for months and still blatantly sees others on the side -- business as usual, nothing changed. Maybe it works for them.

We scrambled some eggs, ate nervously, made some polite small talk, hugged everybody (except you know who!) and scrambled out of there.

It was the latest in a string of "he's a cheater" experiences in my dating life.

Is the Internet and all of our high tech toys (like instant messaging and cellphones) to blame for what seems to continue steamrolling into a total erosion of traditional values in our culture?

Or is it just me? Am old fashioned and out of step in this new age of "polyamory" and NSAs and FWBS and "hook ups" -- and just not getting with it?

It just feels like an avalanche of cheating, dishonesty and two-timing is falling all around me, and I sit here in the midst of it, wanting just one simple thing: Someone to hold, to trust, to love, to unwrap gifts with, to share the warmth with. And I wonder why something so basic, so human, so simple to ask continues to elude me?

6 comments:

Anonymous said...

I was sitting here feeling sorry for myself that I would be alone and single for the holidays. I was thinking that if I saw one more advert for diamond tennis bracelets, I was going to scream.

Then I came upon this site and saw the headline. It was my story, minus the cuddle party. I had the same thing happen to me. My X cheated on me with someone that was willing to tolerate his cheating. Finally after months of lies and tears I had had enough of the deceit and baled. He continues to contact me off and on, even though he's with her now. I don't respond but I'm still not healed, haven't really moved on and feel crushed that he would leave me for someone that clearly has no real sense of morality but then he doesn't either.

The last paragraph of your post was especially poignant. There IS an avalanche of cheating and it's tearing at the fabric of our dating culture. I ask myself how can I ever trust a man again after investing two years of my life in a relationship where he ended up betraying me? How do I trust future boyfriends, will they be "tempted" to "hook up" with willing women or keep FWBS' on the side? There seems to be a whole industry that has sprung up concerning the habits of men and how to hold onto them. Apparently men have lost control of themselves and a woman is only able to "catch a man and keep him" if she reads Cosmo religiously. Men are so complicated these days.

Of course this is all ridiculous. I agree with you that the "Dating Industrial Complex" has convinced men they are in such demand that they can just swap out women at the drop of a hat. And it's convinced women there is a man shortage. If they don't want to die alone they have to resort to predatory behavior. as in chasing committed men.

Like you, all I'm looking for is something real. Someone to hold, someone that has my back and I have theirs. Does that even exist anymore?

Anonymous said...

I think it exists in brief moments when we reach out to other people. I'm finding when I look outside myself, and my own pain, and talk to my friends (and even strangers) there are a lot of lonely people out there who are struggling to connect. We need to remember we are not alone, and make an effort to come together.

Anonymous said...

I think if everyone is "cheating" then there is something wrong with the rules. The idea of having sex with only one other partner over the course of 60+ years has been shown over and over again not to be something most people truly want. And why should it be? Is it cheating on your son to have another a baby? Is it cheating of your best sister to marry a guy and have babies with him? Love and bonds and kinship and loyalty are all interrelated, but all in degrees. I think it is our expectations that cause more problems than the inevitable behavior that comes from people following their heart's desires.

I think it is the lying and pretending that are the problem, necessitated by the judgment that wanting to have a sexual relationship with more than one person at a time is wrong. I don't think it's any worse (or really even as bad) to want to have two sex partners as it is to want to have 3 children. You all learn to share your love and affection.

Anonymous said...

I disagree that it's distaste for the concept of a 50+ year marriage that encourages people to cheat - let's face it, too many people can't even deal with having sex with the same person for 2+ years and generally don’t dare to look any further into the future than next week.

No, I think it's that men are no longer shamed by society for cheating - in fact, society expects it from them, and gives them a playful rap on the knuckles when it happens. (Boys will be boys!) And women tolerate it from their men, too. (Oh well, at least he hasn't left me for that hottie in accounting, and the kids still have a devoted dad.)

A flipside of women tolerating it is that nowadays many women are extremely well groomed, and will go to great lengths to please a man. It’s competitive to the max, and every woman knows it. The ever-present threat that women deal with is: if you don’t keep him happy, he’ll look elsewhere. And yes, he will.

There are so many ways for men to cheat EASILY these days - from my own experiences, I'm convinced that most men see online dating as nothing more than a cheap escort service. They know they can play women off against each other, try them out for a bit, and discard them if they don’t suit all for the price of a hot meal.

Online dating is a man’s world – it’s not a woman’s world, by any means. Sure, hopeful women are chosen and chased, and men are not, but what for? No one’s answering that (at least not out loud.) For no strings sex, and RARELY anything else. Why aren’t women telling the truth about their experiences to combat the handful of “success stories?” Because they’re ashamed, because they’re embarrassed that they brought the men’s lies, because it’s kind of humiliating when you realise that no matter what your intentions, men assume that every woman on online dating websites is desperate so therefore deserves to be treated as an escort. And because online dating is a massive money-making industry, that sells men and dreams (that just aren’t compatible.)

Plus many single women over the age of 30 do operate from a "whatever" position of "I'll have what she's having" because society tells them they can't do any better, and many are very, very angry that they’ve spent 15+ years jumping through hoops for men who ultimately hit and run, while other women who may or may not have played the game any better, got a keeper. So they think “who cares?” At least he’s proven he knows how to treat a woman well. Starving women don’t pause to think about who they’re stealing their food (sustenance, nutrition) from.

Anyway, these are some sweeping generalisations, but they’re also what I’ve noticed in my country. I think the bottom line is that men and women are being sold completely different, and completely incompatible dreams, to keep them greasing the cogs of capitalism (yes, including shrink fees.)

Clever Elsie said...

@Anonymous 12/28: You said: "I don't think it's any worse (or really even as bad) to want to have two sex partners as it is to want to have 3 children. You all learn to share your love and affection."

Oh, really? If it were so natural for men and women to just "learn to share their love and affection," why isn't polyamory more popular? Instead it seems like it doesn't have a very good track record of success. Personally, I've known of a number of couples who've tried all kinds of different "open" arrangements. Funny that none of them are together anymore, and their relationships all ended with significant pain and trauma to at least one party.

@Anonymous 2/2: Although I don't think online dating is solely to blame and I HAVE had good experiences through dating sites, it certainly does make it easier for those who are inclined to cheat. I've dated one man who cheated (didn't meet him OL) and plenty of others who strung me along only to drop me when something presumably better appeared. You're right that it's frustrating, depressing, and eventually soul-crushing.

There's an epidemic of people who are single and DON'T want to be but can't find each other because they only have eyes for the movie star lookalike in their heads. In addition to this atmosphere of dissatisfaction, another root problem is that too many women have bought the lie that sex has no emotional consequences, so there's always some girl (often a young one who doesn't know any better yet) willing to be a guy's FWB or woman on the side. If there weren't so many women willing to compromise themselves like this, guys wouldn't get the idea that they could continuously "sample the goods" and move on. OL dating facilitates this behavior, but it's not responsible for it.

The feminist movement was important, but it went too far. After centuries of being taught to keep our legs closed, now we're pressured to keep them open all the time. When are we going to reclaim our right to have sex only when we are getting our emotional needs met?

cameronsharpe said...

Your story was extremely touching. Your expressiveness demonstrates what an incredible connection you had with this other person and I can sympathize and relate to every word.

Post a Comment

Let us know what you think!